Гдз по русс яз бархударов 8 класс: ГДЗ упражнение 229 русский язык 8 класс Бархударов, Крючков

lhevdh hl ^ _evguf dZdbf lh g_h [udgh \ _gguf ex ^ yf KlZlv

ojZ [juf fh`_l dZ` ^ uc Gm`gh lhevdh ^ he] h_ \ j_fy kbkl_fZlb

q_kdb \ hkiblu \ Zlv k_ [y \ lZdhf ^ mo_ ijbmqblv k_ [y kemrZlvky

k \ hbo ijbdZah \ l \ _j ^ h \ uihegylv lh qlh j_rbe k ^ _eZlv

F = jhfh \

>

@>

@>] e @ qlh

Lbi j_qb

± jZkkm` ^ _gb_: \ lhj ^ hghkbl ^ h qblZl_ey fukev

qlh ojZ [jhklv ± dZq_kl \ h dhlhjh_ fh`gh \ k _ [_ \ hkiblZlv b ^ h dZau \ Z_l wlh gZ ijhklhf ijbf_j_ ijb \ h ^ blg © mijz oj`g_j_ ijb \ h ^ blg © mijZ oj_j_j_ijb \ h ^ blg © mijZ oj_j_j_ijb \ h ^ blg © mijz o j`g_000]

, B] jZ_l \ q_f «\ ojZ [jhklb ± kms ,, G n ± ojZ [jhklv Ihkl gZjbp g_h ^ mr` j kde

G_ihkl \ nhjf_ ij_^e iZ^ _^ q

,,,B]jZ_l jhev ]^_»\ ojZ[jhklb± h[klhyl_evkl\h

, < bxevkdb_ \_q_jZ b ghqb m`_ g_ djbqZl i_j_i_eZ b dhjhkl_eb g_ ihxl \ e_kguo [ZehqdZo kheh\vb g_ iZog_l p\_ lZfb gh kl_iv \kz _sz ij_djZkgZ b ihegZ `bagb ?^\Z aZc^zl khegp_ b a_fex hdmlZ_l f]eZ dZd ^g_\gZy lhkdZ aZ[ulZ \kz

Ihkl gZjbp h^mr bf__l nhjfm lhevdh fg q

G_ihkl \ nhjf_ \bg iZ^

,,,< ij_^eh`_gbb± ^hiheg_gb_

9-Russky_yazyk_9kl_Barkhudarov_2000_Otvety[1] — Стр 13

G H Ih \_q_jZf hl qZy ^h m`bgZ y qblZe ohay_\Zf \kemo F = AZ j_dhc DZf_gdhc gZ gbadhf iheh]hf [_j_]m ijbldgmeZkv fZe_gvdZy ^_j_\mrdZ F K Iha^gh \_q_jhf lh _klv qZkh\ \ h^bggZ^pZlv y ihrze ]meylv ih ebih\hc Zee__ [mev\ZjZ E

Ihjhkev beb fheh^hc e_k ijbylgZ gZ \a]ey^ :dk LboZy jZ ^hklv beb ]jmklv ijh[_]Z_l ih ebpm fZl_jb I_kd ;_kklu^kl \h R\Z[jbgZ qmlv f_gy g_ \a[_kbeh gh gbdlh djhf_ f_gy g_ ih gye ]jm[uo _]h h[bgydh\ I Zevr_ dbehf_ljZ gZ ihelhjZ gZ \ujh\g_gghf ihehlg_ e_`Zeb ^ebggu_ ihe_gbsZ keh\gh ih\Ze_gguc \_ljhf qZklhdhe G H

,Dhg_qgh g_ h^bg ?\]_gbc kfyl_gv_ LZgb \b^_lv fh]

$[ fh`_l [ulv _z ex[h\v ^jma_c kh_^bgbeZ [ \gh\v D g_kqZ klvx EZjbgu lZsbebkv [hykv ijh]hgh\ ^hjh]bo g_ gZ ihqlh\uo gZ k\hbo >Zc gygy fg_ i_jh [mfZ]m ^Z klhe ih^\bgv Ijh klbl_ fbjgu_ ^hebgu b \u agZdhfuo ]hj \_jrbgu b \u agZdhfu_ e_kZ Ijhklbfky ^jm`gh h xghklv ez]dZy fhy M\u LZlvygZ m\y^Z_l [e_^g__l ]Zkg_l b fheqbl G_l h[tykgbkv [_a hl]h\hjhd b ijhklh ijyfh hl\_qZc GZ k\_l_ kqZklvy g_l gh _klv ihdhc b \h ey Hg g_ kh\k_f ijZ\ ^Z b g_ kh\k_f \bgh\Zl >Z fg_ m^Z\Z ehkv k_]h^gy dZ`^h_ ^\b`_gb_ dZ`^h_ keh\h : K Imrdbg

,,L_[_ DZ\dZa kmjh\uc pZjv a_feb y kgh\Z ihk\ysZx klbo g_[j_`guc E Ih fg_gbx a^_rgbo mqzguo wlhl ijh\Ze _klv g_ qlh bgh_ dZd m]Zkrbc djZl_j E LbrbgZ gZ jZkk\_l_ g_ mk ihdZb\ZeZ Z gZh[hjhl mkbeb\ZeZ \heg_gb_ IZmkl Y _sz g_ [ue a^_kv gZ [_j_]m g_ ohq_lky \h i_j\uo eZablv ih ]heuf kdZ eZf Z \h \lhjuo g_ \ q_f =hgq BlZd y \Zf kh\_lmx dZd ijb yl_ev [ulv hklhjh`g__ E LZgd \uklj_ebe _sz g_kdhevdh jZa b dZd ij_^\b^_e Kbgph\ j_rbe ih^hclb [eb`_ Kbf

K_]h^gy \^jm] ih^me \_l_j b [Zjhf_lj klZe iZ^Zlv=hgq EmgZ [_eZ ijhajZqgZ b dZdhc fy]dbc k\_l ev_l hgZ gZ

\k_ =hgq G_ lh [ueh jZgg__ mljh g_ lh m` gZklmiZe \_q_jNZ^ GZ^h fghc rbjhdh_ ]hem[h_ g_[h b ghkylky [hevrb_ [_eu_ ilbpu Q Dh]^Z ^uf jZkk_yeky gZ a_fe_ e_`ZeZ jZg_ gZy ehrZ^v b \hae_ g__ ;weZ E EZd_c m`_ ^\Z jZaZ ih^oh^be d I_qhjbgm k ^hdeZ^hf qlh \k_ ]hlh\h E Hg hdZaZeky agZ dhfuf ^_\mrdb b dh]^Z ^\bgmeky Z\lh[mk kdZaZe _c g_kdhevdh keh\ qj_a\uqZcgh ihqlbl_evgh b \ lh `_ \j_fy ih hl_q_kdbNZ^ Y ihkeZe kijhkblv fh`gh eb hklZgh\blvky qZkZ gZ ^\Z kh]j_lvky =hgq Keurm dZd ^m[u \_^ml [_k_^m dZd e_kghc jmq_c [_`bl \ h\jZ] FZjr ;hehlZ lZd aZ^_j`Zeb gZk qlh fu g_ fh]eb ^h_oZlv ^h klZgpbb b hklZgh\bebkv \ imklhc [jh r_gghc xjl_ ]^_ jZa\_eb h]hgv ibeb qZc b ghq_\Zeb =hgq

Dh]^Z hg>I_qhjbg@himklbeky gZ kdZfvx lh ijyfhc klZg _]h kh ]gmeky dZd [m^lh m g_]h \ kibg_ g_ [ueh gb h^ghc dhklhqdb E

< ]hkih^kdbc ^hf Fmfm g_ oh^beZ b dh]^Z =_jZkbf ghkbe \ dhfgZlu ^jh\Z \k_]^Z hklZgZ\eb\ZeZkv gZaZ^b b g_l_j i_eb\h _]h \u`b^ZeZ m djuevpZ L HdZaZehkv qlh ohly ^hd lhj b ]h\hjbe hq_gv kdeZ^gh b ^he]h gbdZd g_evay [ueh i_j_^Zlv lh]h qlh hg ohl_e kdZaZlv E L <^jm] lZd kl_fg_eh qlh y ihki_rbe \_jgmlvky ^hfhc b ohly fh`gh [ueh jZa]ey^_lv h[ s__ gZijZ\e_gb_ ljhibgdb gh y h^gZdh \_jgmeky ^hfhc k jZa [bluf e[hf b [hevguf dhe_ghf gZldgm\rbkv ki_j\Z gZ kmd Z aZl_f gZ dZdhc lh i_gv F FZd =jb]hjv_\ ihklmibe \ ZdZ ^_fbx b lZd dZd y hlijZ\eyeky \ I_l_j[mj] hg ijhkbe f_gy g_ f_^e_ggh ih[u\Zlv m _]h ^jm]Z Dhj Y h[jZlbeky d dhfZg^b jm dhj\_lZ k ijhkv[hc ^Zlv fg_ q_l\_jdm >q_luj_o\_k_evgZy eh^dZ@ qlh[u hlijZ\blvky gZ [_j_] gh dh]^Z magZe qlh ^ey [_ ahiZkghklb ij_^eh`_gh hlijZ\blv _s_ b dZl_j k \hhjm`_gghc dhfZg^hc y ihijhkbe ^Zlv fg_ rexidm [_a fZljhkh\ F FZd

Fu j_rbeb qlh gZf m`_ g_evay [hevr_ hklZ\Zlvky \ wlhf ]h jh^_ b qlh dh]^Z y ^h[m^m g_fgh]h ^_g_] lh fu i_j__^_f dm^Z gb[m^v \ ^jm]h_ f_klh Q

LHQD: K A:IYLHC

< ms_ev_ g_ ijhgbdZe _sz jZ^hklguc emq fheh^h]h ^gy hg ahehlbe lhevdh \_job mlzkh\ \bkysbo k h[_bo klhjhg gZ^ gZfb ]mklhebkl\_ggu_ dmklu jZklmsb_ \ bo ]em[hdbo lj_ sbgZo ijb fZe_cr_f ^uoZgbb \_ljZ hkuiZeb gZk k_j_[jyguf ^h`^zf E Ghqvx ^h`^v ijhrze ohly mljh [ueh ij_djZk gh_ fu \u_oZeb g_ lZd jZgh ihlhfm qlh gZf gZ^h[gh [ueh i_ j__oZlv \k_]h iylgZ^pZlv \zjkl ^h IZjZrbgZ ]^_ hl_p ohl_e ijh[ulv p_euc ^_gv :dk Dh]^Z fu ih^hreb d ijZ\hfm [_ j_]m fg_ mdZaZeb lZf ]^_ y f_gvr_ \k_]h h`b^Ze madmx ljhim \\_jo lhevdh k ihfhsvx dhjg_c b \_l\_c fh`gh [ueh ^h[jZlv ky ^h iehsZ^db hldm^Z ljhibgdZ klZgh\beZkv rbj_ b hleh`_F FZd

> @ > _ _@ > _ _«@

> @ohly> @ihlhfm qlh ]^_

dh]^Z>lZf ]^_«@ >kms@ hldm^Z

>

Ijbf_lu k\yaZgu kh \k_f k p\_lhf g_[Z k jhkhx b lmfZgZfb k djbdhf ilbp b yjdhklvx a\za^gh]h g_[Z IZmkl

EhrZ^b k aZbg^_\_\rbfb fhj^Zfb b [hdZfb \_aeb jZaguc ohayc kl\_gguc ]jma k_gh l_jfhku k ]hjyq_c ibs_c ^jh\Z :`Z_\

]eZaZ@ b \b`m fhc DZjZ]za e_lbl jZa \_\Zy o\hkl E Ih]h^Z [ueZ m`ZkgZy \_l_j rlhjfh\hc j_ \_e k ghqb ^h`^v ebe dZd ba \_^jZ =hgq Y \hrze \ oZlm ^\_ eZ\db b klhe ^Z h]jhfguc kmg^md khklZ\eyeb \kx _z f_[_ev E

Qbqbdh\ dZd fu m`_ \b^_eb j_rbeky \h\k_ g_ p_j_fhgblvky b ihlhfm \ay\rb \ jmdb qZrdm k qZ_f b \eb\rb lm^Z njmdlh\hc ih\ze lZdb_ j_qb©M \Zk fZlmrdZ ohjhrZy ^_j_\_gvdZ Kdhevdh

\ g_c ^mr»ª = KZf QZpdbc ijh k\hz \j_fy \ujZ`Z_lky lZd ©L_i_jv \hevg__ \kydbc ^urblª=hgq

LBJ?

GZmqblvky m\Z`Zlv k_[y ± ^_eh g_ez]dh_ Nmjf

Ghq_\ZeZ lmqdZ ahehlZy gZ ]jm^b mlzkZ \_ebdZgZ E E_k± wlh b ^j_\_kbgZ b qbkluc \ha^mo b hojZgZ \h^guo bklhqgbdh\ =Za

>ey f_gy `blv ± agZqbl jZ[hlZlv :c\Zah\kdbc Emqrbc jZaf_j dgb]b ± ^\_klb kljZgbp IZmkl <_kzeh_ kha^Zgv_ lu `b\h_ =j K_j^p_ g_ dZf_gv Ih_e E_k dZd iZjd =hgq

hfZ Nhfm \klj_lbeb lhj`_kl\_ggh hl_p ih^Zjbe fZevqbdm ly`zemx k_j_[jygmx eh`dm k aZl_ceb\uf \_ga_e_f Z lzldZ± rZjn k\h_]h \yaZgby F = < \_klb[xe_ \ dhjb^hjZo \ dZ[bg_lZo± \kx^m lheibebkv ex^b Jm`vz kh [ZdZ ehrZ^v± \kz [ueh ij_^f_lhf f_gu gh \h\k_ g_ k l_f qlh [u \ub]jZlv ± wlh ijhbkoh^beh ijhklh hl dZdhc lh g_m]hfhgghc xjdhklb b [hcdhklb oZjZdl_jZ = Ih\kx^m ± \ dem[_ gZ mebpZo gZ kdZf_cd_ m \hjhl \ ^hfZo± ijhbkoh^beb rmfgu_ jZa ]h\hju =Zjr H^gZ`^u om^hc ju[heh\ \ \uebgy\r_c lm j_pdhc n_kd_ \ulZsbe fhjkdh]h i_lmoZ ± hq_gv j_^dmx b kZfmx ijbqm^eb\mx ju[m gZ Qzjghf fhj_ IZmkl < ^Zevg_f m]em k\_lbehkv `zelh_ iylgh ± h]hgv \ hdg_ d\Zjlbju K_jZnbfZ ijb kljh_gghc d kl_g_ dhgxrgb F = < ]h^u \hcgu kljhbl_ev [_lhgsbd klZe khe^Zlhf kZizjhf Ihe H^gZ aZ ^jm]hc ih^ oh^yl d ^hfm `_gsbgu dj_klvygdb Nmjf

Y [ue m]jxf± ^jm]b_ ^_lb \_k_eu b [heleb\u Y ]h\h jbe ijZ\^m ± fg_ g_ \_jbeb E I_k_gdZ dhgqbeZkv ± gZqZebkv h[uqgu_ jmdhie_kdZgby L ;m^_l ^h`^bd ± [m^ml b y]h^dbIhke Hg aZkf_zlky± \k_ ohohqml gZkmibl [jh\b± \k_ fheqZlI Kehc h[eZdh\ [ue hq_gv lhghd± kd\hav g_]h ijhk\_qb\Zeh khegp_ IZmkl <^jm] ^\_jv dZfhjdb [ukljh jZkiZogmeZkv± \ky q_ey^v lhlqZk dm[Zj_f kdZlbeZkv k e_klgbpu L

ky \ \ukhdmx ]jy^dm iheugb gZ f_`_ GZ^ \Zfb djm]hf \Zk± \kx ^m lmfZg L ©IjZ\h hklZgvl_kv IZ\_e B\Zgh\bqª ± kdZaZe FZgbeh\ dh]^Z \ureb gZ djuevph = ©>Z g_ ihaZ[m^vl_ B\Zg =jb]hjv_\bq ± ih^o\Zlbe Kh[Zd_\bq ± gm`gh [m^_l k\b^_ l_e_c ohly [u ih ^\Z k dZ`^hc klhjhguª=

± Ih djZcg_c f_j_ agZ_l_ FZgbeh\Z» ± kdZaZe Qbqbdh\

± : dlh lZdhc FZgbeh\»

± Ihf_sbd fZlmrdZ

± G_l g_ keuob\ZeZ g_l lZdh]h ihf_sbdZ =

KDH;DB

IlbpZ dZd ]h\hjyl hohlgbdb reZ \Zehf b \ [_kihjy^ d_ L Fg_ y \Zf wlh ijyfh kdZ`m gygqblvky k \Zfb lh`_ g_ dh]^Z : = Hg >Ljh_dmjh\@ \_e_e aZijyqv [_]h\u_ ^jh`db h^_eky ihl_ie__ wlh [ueh m`_ \ dhgp_ k_gly[jy b kZf ijZ\y ih_oZe kh ^\hjZ I F_klghklv kZf \b^brv [_aex^gZy IZ mkl

D:

Y kgh\Z ihkm^gbdhf gZ iZjhoh^_©I_jfvª[_ehf dZd e_[_^v ijhklhjghf b [ukljhf F = IjhsZykv k ^_\hqdhc y ihijhkbe ©KdZ`b fZf_ qlh y hq_gv [eZ]h^Zjx _z hq_gv KdZ `_rv»ª F = ©Kem`blv [u jZ^ ijbkem`b\Zlvky lhrghª ± gZf_dZ_l hg kZf>QZpdbc@=hgq Dhf_^by ^Zzl QZpdhfm lhev dh ©fbevhg l_jaZgbcª =hgq Keh\hf wlh q_eh\_d g_ lhevdh mfguc gh b jZa\blhc beb dZd j_dhf_g^m_l _]h ]hjgbqgZy EbaZ hg©qm\kl\bl_e_g b \_k_e b hklzjª=hgq IhklZ\sbdb fZl_ jbZeZ gZ [mfZ`gu_ nZ[jbdb ihjmqZxl aZdmidm ljyivy hkh[_ggh ]h jh^Z ex^yf dhlhju_ \ bguo m_a^Zo gZau\Zxlky©hjeZfbªL

Kulbg \ dgb`ghf ^_e_ ku]jZe h]jhfgmx jhev b bfy _]h l_kgh k\yaZgh k bklhjb_c ijbh[s_gby gZjh^guo fZkk d i_qZlgh fm keh\m b jmkkdhc ebl_jZlmj_

©GZ ^gyo y [ue m KulbgZ b agZdhfbeky k _]h ^_ehf± ibr_l : I Q_oh\ \ ]h^m \ ibkvf_ d Km\hjbgm ± Bgl_j_kgh \ \ukr_c kl_i_gb Wlh gZklhys__ gZjh^gh_ ^_eh Ih`Zemc wlh _^bgkl\_ggZy \ Jhkkbb ba^Zl_evkdZy nbjfZ ]^_ jmkkdbf ^mohf iZog_l b fm`bdZ g_ lhedZxl \ r_x Kulbg ± mfguc q_eh\_d b jZkkdZau\Z_l bgl_j_kgh Dh]^Z kemqblky

Ghqmxl ihdmiZl_eb ± wlh hq_gv fgh]hagZqbl_evgh b oZjZd

9-Russky_yazyk_9kl_Barkhudarov_2000_Otvety[1]

>hfZrgyy jZ[hlZ ih jmkkdhfm yadm

aZ deZkk

d mq_[gbdm©Jmkkdbc yaud deZkkª ;Zjom^Zjh\Z K = b ^j F©Ijhk\_s_gb_ª]

mq_[gh ijZdlbq_kdh_ ihkh[b_

KH>?J@:GB?

F_`^mgZjh^gh_ agZq_gb_ jmkkdh]h yaudZ

KBGL:DKBK B IMGDLM:PBY

Ih\lhj_gb_ kbglZdkbkZ keh\hkhq_lZgby

b ijhklh]h ij_^eh`_gby

KEH@GH? IJ?>EH@?GB?

Hkgh\gu_ \b^u keh`guo ij_^eh`_gbc

KHXAGU? KEH@GU? IJ?>EH@?GBY KEH@GHKHQBG,GGU?IJ?>EH@?GBY

Hkgh\gu_ ]jmiiu keh`ghkhqbg_gguo ij_^eh`_gbc ih agZq_gbx b khxaZf

AgZdb ij_ibgZgby \ keh`ghkhqbg_gghf ij_^eh`_gbb

KEH@GHIH>QBG,GGU?IJ?>EH@?GBY

Kljh_gb_ keh`ghih^qbgzggh]h

ij_^eh`_gby b imgdlmZpby \ gzf

Keh`ghih^qbgzggu_ ij_^eh`_gby

k ijb^Zlhqgufb hij_^_ebl_evgufb

Keh`ghih^qbgzggu_ ij_^eh`_gby

k ijb^Zlhqgufb batykgbl_evgufb

Keh`ghih^qbgzggu_ ij_^eh`_gby

k ijb^Zlhqgufb h[klhyl_evkl\_ggufb

KEH@GHIH>QBG,GGU?IJ?>EH@?GBY

K G?KDHEVDBFB IJB>:LHQGUFB

Hkgh\gu_ \b^u keh`ghih^qbgzgguo ij_^eh`_gbc

k ^\mfy beb g_kdhevdbfb ijb^Zlhqgufb b imgdlmZpby \ gbo

;?KKHXAGU? KEH@GU? IJ?>EH@?GBY

AZiylZy b lhqdZ k aZiylhc

\ [_kkhxaghf keh`ghf ij_^eh`_gbb

>\h_lhqb_ \ [_kkhxaghf keh`ghf ij_^eh`_gbb

Lbj_ \ [_kkhxaghf keh`ghf ij_^eh`_gbb

KEH@GU? IJ?>EH@?GBY

K J:AEBQGUFB :FB K

Keh`gu_ ij_^eh`_gby k jZaebqgufb \b^Zfb khxaghc

b [_kkhxaghc k\yab b imgdlmZpby \ gbo

H;SB? K?GBY H YAUD?

Jhev yaudZ \ `bagb h[s_kl\Z

Yaud dZd bklhjbq_kdb jZa\b\Zxs__ky y\e_gb_

Jmkkdbc ebl_jZlmjguc yaud b _]h klbeb

IH

E?DKBD: NJ:A?HEH=BY HJNH=J:NBY

KHKL:< KEH<:

B KEH

FHJNHEH=BY HJNH=J:NBY

KMS?KL

QBKEBL?EVGH? F?KLHBF?GB?

=E:=HE

G:J?QB?

IJ?>EH= KHXA Q:KLBP:

KBGL:DKBK IMGDLM:PBY

MIHLJ?;E?GB?AG:DH< IJ?IBG:GBY

LHQD:

B

A:IYL:Y

LHQD: K A:IYLHC

>

LBJ?

KDH;DB

D:

F_`^mgZjh^gh_ agZq_gb_ jmkkdh]h yaudZ

gbyF_`^mgZjh^gh_ agZq_gb_ yaudZ ihdZaZgh \ l_dkl_ mijZ`g_

KBGL:DKBK B IMGDLM:PBY

Ih\lhj_gb_ kbglZdkbkZ keh\hkhq_lZgby b ijhklh]h ij_^eh`_gby

Kl_exsb_ky jZkl_gby ]mklu_ aZjhkeb ykgh baeZ]Zlv ih^ ]hlh\blvky d baeh`_gbx ih^[bjZlv fZl_jbZe aZi_j_lv dexqhf \ha\jZsZlvky e_khf ohjhrh hjb_glbjh\Zlvky \ujZklblv \ l_i ebp_ aZgbfZlvky \ [b[ebhl_d_ ez]dh_ ijbdhkgh\_gb_ ijh\_klb dZkZl_evgmx aZ]hj_lvky hl \aju\Z ijb_oZlv jZ[hlZlv fbjh\ha aj_gb_ ibkZl_ey

IhklZjZcl_kv ykgh baeZ]Zlv k\hb fukeb Ih[m^bl_evgh_ Qlh[u ih^]hlh\blvky d baeh`_gbx gZ^h ohjhrh hjb_glbjh

\Zlvky \ ebl_jZlmj_ Ih\_kl\h\Zl_evgh_

GZibkZgb_ keh\ k ijhims_ggufb [md\Zfb hkgh\Zgh gZ ke_ ^mxsbo ijZ\beZo q_j_^h\Zgb_ ]eZkguo \ dhjgyo keh\ baeZ ]Zlv \ujZklblv b ^j ± [he__ madh_ ijZ\beh ijh\_jy_fu_ ]eZkgu_ \ dhjgyo keh\ ohjhrh \ l_iebp_ b ^j± [he__ rbjhdh_

L_iebpZ± l_ieh kmnnbdkZevguc

Fbjh\haaj_gb_ ± fbj \haaj_gb_ ± aj_gb_ iml_f keh`_gby hk gh\

Qlh fh`_l [ulv aZf_qZl_evg__ b bgl_j_kg__ i_s_j»

\udZ_rv d k\_lm ^jh`Zs_c k\_qb Ih\_kl\ g_\hkde ijhklh_ h^ghkhkl hij ebqgh_ jZkij ihegh_ Oh^u lygmlky \_l\ylky lh g_h`b^Zggh jZkrbjyxlky \ p_eu_ aZeu lh djmlh kimkdZxlky \gba lh h[ju\Zxlky ijhiZklyfb Gb \_jz\db gb djxqdb gb \_ jz\hqgu_ e_klgbpu ± gbqlh g_ ihfh]Z_l ^hclb ^h g_\_^hfuo ]em[bg qlh[u bamqblv ih^a_fguc eZ[bjbgl

< ]emohc imklhl_ baj_^dZ jZa^Zxlky jZagu_ a\mdb r_e_kl e_ lmqbo fur_c b f_jguc rmf iZ^Zxsbo dZi_ev b ]emob_ jZkdZlu h[ju\Zxsboky ih^ gh]Zfb dZfg_c Bgh]^Z [_eu_ lzfgu_ djZk gu_ fbg_jZeu k\hbfb hleh`_gbyfb ihdju\Zxl kl_gdb i_s_j Bo ijbqm^eb\u_ nhjfu gZihfbgZxl g_ lh nb]mju dZdbo lh aZklu\ rbo \_ebdZgh\ g_ lh dhklb ]b]Zglkdbo ys_jh\

Ih : ? N_jkfZgm Ih k\h_fm khklZ\m gZebqbx ]eZ\guo qe_gh\ ij_^eh`_gby ij_^eh`_gby ^_eylky gZ ^\m b h^ghkhklZ\gu_ ijbkmlkl\mxl eb

[h h[Z eb[h h^bg ba ]eZ\guo qe_gh\ ij_^eh`_gby ,Ihdju\Zxl qlh ^_eZxl» ± ]eZ]he ,,G n± ihdju\Zlv Ihkl g_kh\ \b^ i_j_o kij G_ihkl baty\ gZde fg q gZkl \j e

,,,< ij_^eh`_gbb± kdZam_fh_ Hleh`_gbyfb± hleh`blv kmnnbdkZevguc =b]Zglkdbo± ]b]Zgl kmnnbdkZevguc

>jm] ImrdbgZ ihwl Yaudh\ \hki_e jmkkdb_ j_db \ bam fbl_evguo klboZo

Imrdbg \i_j\u_ gZibkZe h >hg_ qlh hg g_ l_qzl Z evzlky < wlhf [ueZ m^b\bl_evgZy gbdh]^Z g_ baf_gy\rZy ihwlm lhqghklv hij_^_e_gbc \bgZ >g_ij H[v ± \k_ [hevrb_ jmkkdb_ j_db bf_ggh l_deb Hgb g_keb d fhjyf ly`zeu_ \h^u < rbjhdhf ^\b`_gbb wlbo j_d [ueZ kbeZ gZklhcqb\hklv

: >hg ebeky e_]dh _iha\Zgb\Zy gZ i_j_dZlZo_ _k_j_[jykv hl \_l jZ \f_kl_ k ebklvyfb jZdbl_ Ih\_kl\ g_\hkde ijhklh_ ^\m khkl jZkij ihegh_ hkeh`g_gh h^ghj h[hkh[e_ggufb h[klhy l_evkl\Zfb H[eZdZ f_^e_ggh lhgmeb lmkdg_y \ _]h hfmlZo

I_kqZgu_ dhku i_j_fulu_ ^hgkdhc \h^hc [ueb \u[_e_gu kheg p_f dZd oheklu qlh jZkdeZ^u\Zeb dZaZqdb ih ^hgkdbf [_j_]Zf

D IZmklh\kdbc < l_dkl_ \klj_qZxlky mlhqgyxsb_ qe_gu jZkijhkljZg_ggu_ h[hkh[e_ggu_ hij_^_e_gby b h^ghjh^gu_ hij_^_e_gby klhysb_ ihke_ hij_^_ey_fuo keh\ h[hkh[e_ggu_ h[klhyl_evkl\Z \ujZ

`_ggu_ ^__ijbqZklgufb b kjZ\gbl_evguf h[hjhlZfb

, Lhqghklv dZdZy» g_ baf_gy\rZy± ijbq hkh[Zy nhjfZ ]eZ ]heZ

Ohjhr__ agZgb_ yaudZ \k_]^Z ihfh]Zeh mq_guf ih^_eblvky k\hbfb hldjulbyfb k ex^vfb \_^v bgZq_ bo gbdlh [u g_ ihgye Y \k_]^Z k [hevrbf bgl_j_khf qblZx dgb]b ih ]_h]jZnbb ihlh fm qlh bo Z\lhju ijb^Zxl agZq_gb_ yaudm k\hbo dgb] Fg_ dZ `_lky qlh y gZ kZfhf ^_e_ \b`m ]hju b j_db hd_Zgu hkljh\Z ^Z`_ ]hjh^Z gZ ^jm]hf dhgp_ k\_lZ b ex^_c \ gbo

AgZgby g_h[oh^bfu q_eh\_dm ;_a gbo gbdh]^Z g_ ihemqblv bgl_j_kgmx ijhn_kkbx [_a gbo g_evay `blv ^hklhcgh

KEH@GH? IJ?>EH@?GB?

Hkgh\gu_ \b^u keh`guo ij_^eh`_gbc

GZ^y ijhklbeZkv b ihreZ d k_[_ gZ\_jo e_]eZ b lhlqZk mkgmeZ Q GZ^y m`_ kbevgh lhkdh\ZeZ b dZ`^uc ^_gv ^mfZeZ h fZl_jb b [Z[mrd_ Q >_gv [ue iZkfmjguc gh l_ieuc

;ueh m`_ qZkh\ ^_kylv \_q_jZ b gZ^ kZ^hf k\_lbeZ ihegZy emgZ Q < ^hf_ \k_ m`_ e_]eb gh gbdlh _s_ g_ kiZe Q

Kl_deyggZy ^\_jv gZ [Zedhg [ueZ aZdjulZ qlh[u ba kZ^Z g_ g_keh `Zjhf : G L ?keb imlgbd b^_l ih ^gm ]hjghc ^heb gu hg \b^bl ]hju kh \k_o klhjhg H[j

E_lh \u^Zehkv k_jh_ b oheh^gh_ ^_j_\vy [ueb fhdju_

Ij_^klZ\vl_ k_[_ qlh \u \ iheghf ih^\h^ghf kgZjy`_gbb klhbl_ gZ [_j_]m h^ghc ba [mol X`gh]h ih[_j_`vy DjufZ K^_ eZcl_ ez]dh_ ^\b`_gb_ eZklZfb ± b i_j_^ \Zfb hldjh_lky g_ h[udgh\_gguc fbj DZkdZ^hf kimkdZxlky d fhjx ijb[j_`gu_ kdZeu jblf wlh]h kimkdZ khojZgy_lky b \ ]em[bg_ < lhes_ [b jxah\hc \h^u \klZxl dZf_ggu_ ]b]Zglu ihdjulu_ ]mklhc rZi dhc fhjkdhc ljZ\u ?z imrbklu_ kl_[eb ke_]dZ ihdZqb\Zxlky dh]^Z qmlv r_\_ey eZklZfb \u ijhieu\Z_l_ fbfh Ih^ \h^hc f_gy_lky gZr_ ijb\uqgh_ ©a_fgh_ª ij_^klZ\e_gb_ h jZkklhygb yo b ihwlhfm ij_^f_lu m^Ze_ggu_ \k_]h gZ ^_kylv iylgZ^pZlv f_ljh\ dZ`mlky hq_gv ^Zezdbfb KdZeu gZ\bkZxl b ihqlb hl\_k gh h[ju\Zxlky \ ijhiZklv dhlhjZy ij_^klZ\ey_lky [_a^hgghc Djm]hf pZjbl ihemfjZd \h^Z kh\_jr_ggh g_ih^\b`gZ

H^gh\j_f_gghklv Rhe <_k_e__ b ]jhfq_ \k_o kf_yeky kZf klm^_gl hg `_ kdhj__ \k_o b i_j_klZe F = < dhjhldb_ abf gb_ ^gb a^_kv jZgh kimkdZ_lky kmfjZd aZlh \ gZqZe_ e_lZ g_^_eyfb

kmnnbdkZfb©hfmª ©_fmª ©bª ,;j_a`be qlh ^_eZe» ± ]eZ]he

,,G n± [j_a`blv Ihkl g_kh\ \ g_i_j_o kij G_ihkl baty\ gZde _^ q ijhr \j f j

,,,< ij_^eh`_gbb± kdZam_fh_

,Q_eh\_qdZ dZdh]h»jZafZob\Zxs_]h± ijbq hkh[Zy nhjfZ ]eZ]heZ

,,G n± jZafZob\Zxsbc Ihkl ^_ckl\ iheg n gZkl \j g_kh\ \b^ G_ihkl \ nhjf_ jh^ i _^ q f j

,,,< ij_^eh`_gbb± hij_^_e_gb_

, G_[h aZ\hehdeh lmqZfb b ih a_fe_ ]meye \_l_j ih^ gbfZy k a_feb iuev [mfZ`db b i_jvy Q Y ]ey^_e gZ kqZkl eb\h_ ebph ^y^b b fg_ ihq_fm lh [ueh `Zev _]h Q K

.